Space is hard. It is a cliché that gets thrown around a lot, but its realities are difficult to grasp until you try to build hardware that operates in a vacuum, extreme radiation, and wild thermal cycles—all with zero tolerance for failure. For Earth observation companies, that hardware difficulty is compounded by a business reality: satellite imagery is essentially a data business waiting for its “GPS moment,” hampered by inconsistent supply due to cloud cover.
Suyash Singh, co-founder and CEO of GalaxEye, is attempting to solve this by building India’s first OptoSAR satellite—a system that combines optical cameras with synthetic aperture radar (SAR) to see through clouds and provide consistent, daily imagery. Pranav Agarwal sat down with Suyash to understand the journey from an IIT Madras Hyperloop team to building space tech.
The conversation covered the technical hurdles of synchronising optical and SAR sensors travelling at seven kilometres per second, the realities of miniaturising radars for drones as a frugal testing ground, and how the IN-SPACe reorganisation catalysed the Indian private space ecosystem. Suyash also broke down the economics of Earth observation and what it is like to book a launch slot with SpaceX.
Some of the things they said stuck with us. We’re sharing six of them here.
On the “GPS moment” for Earth observation
Most of us use GPS and satellite communication daily without a second thought, but satellite imaging hasn’t reached that level of commoditisation. Suyash explains that this is largely due to weather dependency—optical cameras can’t see through clouds.
“GPS is commoditised. Communication is done. And then we started digging a little more why it is not commoditised. And the possible reason that we could reach was that there’s no consistency in satellite imagery today. You may get an imagery today, tomorrow it must be cloudy. You can’t get an image. Third day you’ll get it. Again, fourth day you might not get it. Two months of monsoons, no imagery, and then three months later you’ll get one imagery. Will you rely on such kind of service level agreements? Answer is no.
It’s as good as imagine if GPS would have been dependent on weather. You can book your Uber today, but you can’t book your Uber tomorrow. And then Uber will tell you three months later that you can book it today or not. This is where observation stuck. There is no constant input of satellite imagery which is consistent and intuitive to the end user to build a SaaS application on top.”
On why space hardware is unforgiving
If a car breaks down, you take it to a service centre. If a drone fails, you land it and swap a part. Suyash highlights how the inability to repair assets combined with extreme environmental conditions makes space a uniquely brutal domain.
“Space is hard because you cannot get the asset back to repair. For example, you’re using an automotive car, and the gearbox was faultier. You’ll call all the automotive back to your service center, and you’ll change the gearbox and say, ‘Okay, great. Maintenance done. Bye-bye.’ So there’s a lot of allowance to fail on ground, even on drones. You can take it back, change a few things, do something, and there’s zero tolerance in space because you just can’t reach there. So the fact that it is hard is the number one point about that is you can can’t get it back to repair. Most of the things you can repair on Earth, right? But even if a satellite is repairable, you just can’t get it back.
So that is one thing that makes it super hard. Second point, which is much more of a technical explanation, is you have very limited power in space. I mean, you can’t take a transmission line and power plug onto your satellite and say, ‘Okay, I’m getting power from transmission lines.’ So you’re only dependent on sun, which means you’re only dependent on solar panels.”
On miniaturising before space
Space iteration is expensive. Startups in India don’t have the luxury of launching multiple failed satellites to perfect their sensors. GalaxEye’s approach was to miniaturise their radar and test it aggressively on drones and aircraft first.
“The kind of pricing that you’ll get from a foreign vendor to build SAR for you is something a startup can’t afford. So then you have to say, ‘Okay, can I build first a SAR, and then I’ll think about an OptoSAR?’ So the step one was for us to build a SAR, and that was also a moment of realisation that probably there are no SAR companies in the country. Should we put it together and then launch and then reiterate and understand? The answer is no, you’re based in India, you will not be able to find that kind of capital to iterate in space. You can’t send up and then learn from it and do it again and again. Maybe you will have one or two attempts. So we said, ‘Okay, it is better to maybe test out systems in a much more frugal manner.’
So what we did is we miniaturised the SAR and optical in such a way that we can put it on an aircraft or a drone or a HAPS. So for us, the first three years were all about testing whether my sensor really works in a limited environment.”
On integrating optical and SAR (OptoSAR)
Putting a camera and a radar on the same satellite isn’t just about bolting them together. Because they naturally look at the Earth from different angles, aligning them perfectly while travelling at orbital speeds is a profound engineering challenge.
“So if my satellite is above Bangalore, so probably I’m imaging Indore with optical camera, and you are imaging Dubai with SAR. When you put these two sensors by default, then you’re effectively imaging two different areas on space, which is not the objective. So what you really need to do is see and marry these sensors in such a way that they look at the same area, and they do same time imaging. So they have to look... otherwise, satellites move at seven kilometers per second. So when you start imaging and you are delayed by a second in camera or SAR, you’ve lost seven kilometers of concurrent imaging.”
On the realities of launching with SpaceX
SpaceX hasn’t just lowered the cost of launch; they’ve productised the entire experience. Suyash describes the process of booking a rocket ride, which is remarkably similar to buying a commercial flight ticket online.
“SpaceX has done a great job in making their launch slot visible to you on a website or an app, like a booking platform. For example, you’re booking an airplane ticket. You can pretty much book on SpaceX a similar way, you can book a launch. It’s as simple as that. The moment you book the launch, they then get in touch with you to get more information about your asset, your payload, legitimacy of your payload, et cetera. Then you get into a very simple agreement. And then there are payment milestones. So initially you’ll have to pay 10 to 30%, then 50%, 60%. And over the course of your engagement and agreement, you are allowed to pay in milestones.
So once that is done, then there is the exchange of information that, okay, here is how you’re going to attach the payload to the satellite. And then before a duration of the launch, they’re going to give you a guidance that this is the time when you need to reach there. It’s like your train is going to leave the station, so you will have to come at that particular point to hop onto that train.”
On the friction in selling satellite data
While the technology is advanced, the downstream market for satellite imagery remains challenging. Commercial customers don’t want raw pixels or complex analysis; they just want the final, actionable insight.
“I mean, if you are a commodity trader, and if I tell you, ‘Hey, here’s my data. Now you do your own analysis of where is shrimp, how much shrimp is available, how much copper is available, and whatnot,’ you’ll be like, ‘I don’t want to build a R&D team on top of this imagery analytics and do.’ So I think there is still a gap between data providers and insight generators. And that gap is quite big currently, and that causes discomfort to anyone to kind of come and try satellite imagery.
The SaaS companies who can actually build an application to do operations and maintenance of all the transmission lines, they’re not getting the right data at a consistent pace to build a solution for their end users. So imagine you’re a transmission company and I’m a SaaS company. If I promise you that I will give you one image, one report of maintenance where it needs to be done every week, and I didn’t get the images for three weeks because of clouds, then you’re gonna cancel the contract.”
Listen to the full conversation on YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts.
The transcript below was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors.
Pranav Agarwal: I wanna tell you a little about myself, right? When I was four years old, on my almirah, there were photos of Aryabhata and Bhaskara, like the oldest satellites we had, and then later INSAT. I grew up listening to Carl Sagan. I grew up playing Kerbal Space Station, trying to make little rockets go into space.
All of this is to say, it is just incredible that a place like this exists. I cannot tell you how happy I am to have you on the show. Welcome to the pod.
Suyash Singh: Thank you so much, Pranav. Happy to be here.
Pranav Agarwal: So yeah, it strikes me that there are different reasons that you get into different businesses, right? There are some businesses that I find fairly easy to understand having written about businesses for a couple of years.
There are a lot of businesses that look roughly like this, that I have a factory in Gujarat, I import chemical A, I mix it with chemical B. I sell everything at a 10% m- markup, and that is my business. I know why someone gets into that business. I know how that business works. Then there are businesses that are so absolutely terrifying and so confusing that at least I would not even attempt them unless I was driven by some kind of madness.
What is it that makes someone go into the space business?
Suyash Singh: No, that’s an interesting point, and I think there’s a very long answer to that, you know? And I’ll try and kind of, you know, summarize that as much as possible. So, see, I think my journey started back in IIT Madras when I was building Hyperloop and, you know, I, I was doing my master’s in aerospace engineering back in 2017 and 2019, and I was building Hyperloop.
Now, Hyperloop also w- is, is a separate story to tell, but, you know, we were just excited about doing better things at engineering, and Elon Musk just gave us an opportunity to kind of participate in a competition that SpaceX used to organize every year. And, we said, “Yeah, you know, beyond your coursework and stuff, this looks really cool to do and attempt something that is fascinating.” So I think Hyperloop gave us that insight into building tougher systems or, you know, very deep tech, heavy systems, and s- some systems that has never been built before, right? So running a pod in a vacuum tube is, is, is a super novel, super tough, or rather, you know, rather a point where people have not been there before So, so I think we’ve done that when we were at IIT Madras, me and my founders, of course.
But, you know, that was just for fun. You know, and like we were having fun with the science and engineering and whatnot. Space happened to me in a, in a much more organic way than it would happen to anyone else. So post my IIT Madras, I joined a corporate R&D to work on, and that’s where I used to do multiple things.
I used to work across multiple industries here and there. One fine day, I get a problem statement to solve, and that problem statement was California forest fire. I had to quantify the damage caused by the forest fire for a client of ours back then. For some reason, you know, they had to fight a battle with an insurance company so that they can appropriately size the claims and whatnot.
So to do that, I was kind of, you know, like somehow I was the person who was given that task. I said, “Yeah, easy peasy. I can just take a bunch of satellite imageries, run a black box ML algorithm.” Back then it wasn’t called AI that much, but an M- ML algorithm and quantify that entire thing. You know, it was so hard to do that.
You know, the realisation just came when I was, I was trying to do some hands-on So the problem statement was pretty simple. I had to quantify the forest fire, damage that has been caused by forest fire, and I need to quantify and give that as a report to my customer. The moment I started doing it, I found all the camera-like imagery was either smoky or cloudy, or were taken in the nighttime.
Pranav Agarwal: So you couldn’t see what’s actually happening on the earth?
Suyash Singh: Not at all. So it was almost like, you know, 30%, 40%, 80% of the part of the images were just some whitish clouds. You can’t do anything about it. And then, you know, the struggle begin, began exactly at that point in time. Said, “Okay, this problem doesn’t look solvable.” There used to be an ISRO advisor in, of that corporate who advised me then that why don’t you try something called synthetic aperture radar, or SAR, as an imagery? Now, radar by default has abilities to penetrate through smoke, clouds, fog, and so on and so forth. So synthetic aperture radar is a form of radar that people use in space to do imaging.
Just like how you do camera imaging, people use a radar, a synthetic aperture radar to do imaging, but through clouds. So, so that was the first time I’ve ever heard about it, okay, something like this hap- exists. He said, “Try this and you, you’ll get your answers.” I said, “Fantastic.” And trust me, it took me almost two months.
I come from IIT Madras. I know a little bit of math and physics. Yeah. At least a little bit to, to, to attempt that problem. It took me a couple of months to really load that imagery, understand that imagery, and so on and so forth. So it’s, it’s almost like X-ray, where you see black dots, white dots, and, and if you, if you have an hairline fracture or anything and your, your bone is broken, only doctors know that because they’re the experts who can read X-ray.
Similarly, SAR needs doctors, PhDs, right? Like super extremely good experts to understand those imagery and, and tell what’s what. Now, this is something, you know, that came as a scenario towards me that a camera-like imagery was not available because of clouds, and synthetic aperture radar, which was always available, was not understandable.
Suyash Singh: And that was a classic, you know, dilemma to do what, right? And, unfortunately, I could not solve that problem. I was not able to quantify it because I was not able to kind of, you know, put them together side by side and understand what’s happening. But that gave me an idea that... A- and the idea had a story So me and my founders back in Hyperloop started investigating into this particular problem.
Is this the reason why there are almost no unicorns in the downstream of satellite imagery? Let me take a step back. Space has three applications: satellite communications, navigation, Earth observation, imaging. You build a rocket, you build a satellite, you do anything, you’re only solving for these three applications. There’s no fourth application. The fourth application will now become, which is orbital data centers, but there are only three application till date now, which are getting solved from space. Communication, Starlink has just nailed it. You know, Elon Musk’s SpaceX-Starlink combination is everywhere, and they have 10,500 plus satellites in orbit, and it’s so well-connected, and everyone use.
So you use it. Like tomorrow you just have to subscribe from one service provider to Starlink to switch, but your usage is quite clear about the communication. Navigation is also like that. Navigation is, is used by every one of us on a daily basis. We use communication, we use navigation. Use Ola, Uber, Zepto, Zomato, food apps, everything pretty much.
But do you use Earth observation or imaging on a daily basis? Do you, do you task from your phone that I need an imagery of Bangalore of yesterday? You don’t do that, right? Which means the commoditizations of Earth observation has not happened yet. So when we got together after my failed attempt towards quantifying the forest fire problem, we found that only one application of space is not commoditised today, which is imaging.
GPS is commoditised. Communication is done. And then we started digging a little more why it is not commoditised. The ... And the possible reason that we could achieve, reach was that there’s no consistency in satellite imagery today You may get an imagery today Y- tomorrow there must be cloudy. You can’t get an image.
Third day you’ll get it. Again, fourth day you might not get it. Two months of monsoons, no imagery, and then three months later you’ll get one imagery. Will you kind of rely on such kind of service level agreements? Answer is no. It’s, it’s as good as, like, imagine if GPS used, would have been dependent on weather.
You, you can book your Uber today, but you can’t book your Uber tomorrow. Understood. And then Uber will tell you three months later that you can book it today or not. This is where observation stuck.
There is no constant input of satellite imagery which is consistent and intuitive to the end user to build a SaaS application on top. You know, gave us that problem statement to trickle down to a solution if we said, “Can we build a satellite that gives a consistent input of imagery to anyone and everyone?” And that is where we bumped into OptoSAR.
Pranav Agarwal: I think I would love to go a little deeper into what OptoSAR is itself. I think that is the great sort of innovation that GalaxEye has brought to the fore.
But before that, I want to understand what the component systems are that you stitched together. I think b- because both of those themselves are incredible systems- Right ... and, it is only more incredible that you can bring them together. So could you help us understand what an MSI is? I think most people understand what a camera is, the kind of thing that you take a selfie with, but nobody understands what a m- multispectral imager is.
While most people have a broad sense that there are radars, there are those giant dishes that you see here and there, but you don’t know what a synthetic aperture radar is. So could you make these things intuitive for us?
Suyash Singh: So, so I think ... A- and, you know, this is a good segue also, to talk about, you know, why we chose OptoSAR.
So, you know, maybe I’ll start with this and come there. So when we s- when we decided to say that we’ll provide consistent satellite imagery input to anyone and everyone around the world, right? Then we started looking at options, you know, what exists today and what do we need to build. And precisely where, you know, we found that there are multispectral cameras.
Now, now think of your phone’s camera. Your phone’s camera is made up of three bands, red, green, and blue. When you mix these three, you know, whatever you see as a photo or, or a video, it’s a combination of these three bands fused together is what you see. And our eyes are meant to see RGB as a combination.
So th- this is what we actually observe and actually capture. Now, cameras actually, you know, can do more. But in, in our daily life, we don’t need more, so we never capture more bands. We only capture three bands. But when you’re talking about, you know, use cases where you need to do more vegetation analysis, soil health analysis, or you need to do something during the nighttime here and there, that is when you want to capture more data from the light.
So light has a broader spectrum. It’s ... in, in visible range, you have something somewhere from 400 to 2- 2,400 nanometers. This is, this is how the broadband, you know, you get from the visible and IR spectrum. But what we choose to see generally on a day-to-day life is only three bands out of it, so red, green, and blue.
But what you can capture from camera is much wider.
Pranav Agarwal: So could you give me one concrete example, maybe with soil health? What would ... If I went with an iPhone camera and clicked it versus if I had a multispectral imager, what would the differences be? What more would I get?
Suyash Singh: So, so I’ll take vegetation, which is the most popular example, right?
so regular camera will give you the picture of, say, a leaf. You, you’ll see a green leaf, you know, in front of you, but it will not tell you, you know, the health of that green leaf in a greater detail. So I, I just want to know, you know, what is the vegetation health of that leaf in that image. The moment I want to know that, I will have to capture one more band.
It’s called NIR, or near infrared. Now, if I do a match between near infrared and red band, in some way I’ll be able to plot, you know, on which area of leaf it- the vegetation is high. Or rather, you know, maybe it’s a bad example, but take a photograph of any random place. On the trees, there is vegetation.
The building is not vegetated. So in, when I do the calculation with near-infrared band and red band, it will precisely tell me that, okay, only this area is vegetated.
Pranav Agarwal: Hmm. Fascinating.
Suyash Singh: So basically, you will, you’ll be able to uncover insights of what is vegetated and what is not.
Pranav Agarwal: And from that we attach a SAR. So what is that?
Suyash Singh: So I think, before I go there, maybe I’ll give you one more example, right? Now, I need to know the soil moisture index, right? So then I will need a bunch of other bands in the same spectrum. I’ll pull them in, do an algebraic, you know, calculation of that, and that will tell me which part of the soil is, soil has water and which part of the soil doesn’t have water.
So you can actually... You know, if you’re taking a field, photo from space, in the larger agricultural field, it can tell where it is mo- or, you know, where the water is, where the water is not. And this has been used in multiple applications to understand, you know, which... Where is irrigation required? Where is irrigation not required?
Which part is healthier? Which part is not healthier? So, you know, based on your application, you can choose which band you want to capture and then convert, them into either a vegetation index or a, you know, a soil moisture index. You can, in fact, sweep them and find more bands. It’s up to research and whatnot.
You can even get a water quality, parameter from, from those calculations. So multispectral is all about finding more health parameters in the wider range of the spectrum And RGB are just visual, you know, band that you see there. Now, when it comes to SAR, SAR is not a visual range spectrum measurement of anything.
So I’m not capturing anything that a human eye can see, right? A radar is more towards microwave. So, you know, in the larger electromagnetic spectrum, SAR is on the, on the microwave range, which means SAR has capability to penetrate through multiple things. SAR also has bands. They have different wavelengths.
Now, an X-band SAR will penetrate through clouds, come down to earth, but cannot penetrate forests. It will reflect back from forests, right? If you go to an L-band SAR, it will penetrate through forests and can see something beneath the forest. And if you go to P-band SAR, it might penetrate through some level of sub-subsurface.
Pranav Agarwal: In under the soil?
Suyash Singh: Under the soil.
Pranav Agarwal: All right.
Suyash Singh: So SAR gives you penetration capabilities because of the wavelength that it carries, so it can see. So now Ka and Ku band will not penetrate anything. It’ll probably reflect from the cloud, probably, right? So, so SAR basically gives you an information where there are obstacles and obstructions, and that is where cloud comes in.
So 70% of the earth is always covered by clouds, so you need to actually see through cloud, and that is why you take an X-band SAR and penetrate through clouds to see and do imaging during a cloudy situation. So that is where SAR comes to help.
Pranav Agarwal: And the synthetic aperture part of it is so that I don’t have to have a massive, like, radar system.
Suyash Singh: Yeah. So synthetic aperture was, a, was an invention because in a static radar, your antenna aperture is a real aperture. So whatever is antenna, that is your basically, you know, meas-measuring capability. But in space, you can’t put, like, massive antennas. So what you do is you use the velocity of the satellite to create a synthetic aperture.
Pranav Agarwal: So you decide, let’s say, that I stitch this together, and I get the benefit of being able to see it visually and also get a sense of what is happening underneath the cloud cover or whatever. Then you say, “Okay, now I actually have to sit and stitch this together.” What is that process like? What are the difficulties you end up with until you actually get the thing going?
Suyash Singh: Great question. I think that’s also, you know, is our IP. So the most important difficulty is, I would say, the way these systems are designed originally. So if you want to take a camera from the market and a radar somebody, let’s say, is building, and w- when you want to put them together on the same platform, you know, the baseline assumption of a lot of people is the camera will always look vertically downwards to earth, and radar by design have to look at an angle.
So if I’m going above, my satellite is above Bangalore, so probably I’m imaging... Or rather, you know, somewhere in mid of India, Indore or, you know, wherever. So you’re probably imaging Indore with optical camera, and you are imaging Dubai with SAR See, so when you put these two sensors, you know, by default, then you’re effectively imaging two different areas on space, which is not the objective, right?
So what you really need to do is see and marry these sensors in a, in such a way that they look at the same area, and they do same time imaging. So they have to look ... So otherwise, satellites move at seven kilometers per second. Seven kilometers per second. So when you start imaging and you are delayed by a second in camera or SAR, you’ve lost seven kilometers of, you know, concurrent imaging.
So I think the difficulty, one, was to make sure that how do they align-
Pranav Agarwal: And you’re trying to get a perfect overlay, so to speak. Perfect overlay, yeah.
Suyash Singh: So, so that is one. And second is, you know, how do you make sure that they image at the same si- same time? See, when you’re opening the, camera shutter and say there’s a microsecond delay, and the radar signals have to also start, and there is some delay.
So if that delay collectively is a second or a couple of seconds delay, so then you’re effectively looking at two different area. So you need to also do a time synchronisation of those two sensors, which don’t come from the same family. One comes from a lens family where you have to put a lens and a, and a detector behind it to make the camera happen, and it captures sunlight or photons.
The other comes from a antenna family where you don’t have a lens, you have an antenna, and that is generating its own signal, sending it to Earth, and getting it back. So you have to now marry an RF situation, a RF signal to a photon. Now, when you put these things together, it becomes complex, right? The sunlight is reflecting in some way.
The signals are reflecting some way. So I think the biggest challenge was how do you synchronize it to make sure that it looks at the same area, captures the images at the same time?
Pranav Agarwal: Fascinating. So one of the things that, you know, so we wrote a couple of times on space as a business, and one of the things that we hadn’t internalized until that moment was that the satellite business, especially Earth observation, is actually a data business. I mean, the collection of the data is beautiful and dramatic, but at the end of the day, you’re sort of s- putting everything on a dashboard or something. make that part of it intuitive for me. So- I have all of the signal. What can I now do with it? What do I unlock? What was previously impossible that is now possible?
You mentioned, for instance, that, you know, currently the issue is that I can’t constantly image Earth, and therefore, there are a lot of applications that can’t happen. Let’s say now that I can, what can I do?
Suyash Singh: So, so like you said, I think number one is, you know, the consistency is getting imparted because of this combination that we’re doing.
Secondly, you know, see, SAR individually have some characteristics that it captures. Multispectral individually does the same for it, right? So for example, I can’t do a vegetation, analysis on SAR most possibly, right? I c- may not be able to do a soil moisture analysis on SAR because SAR is just penetrating.
It is not giving me the measurements of, you know, those areas. So, s- so both brings two different kinds of characteristics. So SAR gives you more geometric understanding. So it can give you precise measurements of the building length or the area, right? It can also be utilized to understand if there is a damage in bridges using some- something called interferometric SAR, right?
It can also tell you, what was deformed or, you know, what, what were the deformations that has happened consistently over time in a particular thing. So I think you’ll get the geometric perturbations captured in SAR You’ll get the reflective measurements captured in optical. And when you combine them both, you know, you actually get the super set of both the worlds.
Pranav Agarwal: So could you give me, like, maybe one thing that most people wouldn’t even realize we can actually go and capture from space that would be unlocked by this technology?
Suyash Singh: I think there are lot, lots of them, by the way, right? So for example, I don’t know, I mean, even I was not completely aware until I started this that, you know, I can, I can do a vegetation analysis, I can do a soil moisture analysis, or I can understand if there is a crack in a bridge from space.
Pranav Agarwal: How thin a crack?
Suyash Singh: Millimeters.
Pranav Agarwal: Wow.
Suyash Singh: Absolutely. In, like, 10, 10 mm, the, those kind of cracks can be captured from space. And, and there is a lot of research that has been done already onto that. So you can do all those things. But the most important point here is, you know, the comprehension on top of these specific technical outcomes and making them as a use case for a larger mass to consume has unfortunately not happened at scale so far.
So it’s just that one thing that we all need to kind of sit down and do that. But to answer your question again, like, I think, one thing that comes to my mind and I was truly fascinated about is, is, is, you know, how can you find those deformations in, in bridges and, also, you know, the variability of the length in, in a, in a forest where you have different trees, but you can still kind of estimate the, the height of the trees from space.
Pranav Agarwal: So you have unlocked the ability to look at things. Now people have to figure out how to make downstream businesses with them.
Suyash Singh: I think we are also doing a bunch of things, Pranav, but, we need to unlock a lot more use cases than we think. We’ve probably not even touched, you know, the tip of the iceberg so far.
Pranav Agarwal: Lovely. So I wanna go to something a little different. So you started in 2021, right? And there is this, like, massive catalytic change that happens around then, which is the reorganization of ISRO. So before that, India basically does not have a private space, industry. the only thing one knows about the private space industry is that entire Antrix-Devas fiasco, and that is about it.
And then there is the reorganization of ISRO, and suddenly you have this entire cohort of very interesting space tech businesses. What is that catalytic event? What is it to live through that? What is it to see, you know, space suddenly become possible as a business venture?
Suyash Singh: Oh, that’s a great question, and I think probably, Galaxay exists because those things got streamlined. I would say the pivotal moment was the liberalization reforms that were brought in place to open the space sector for the private ecosystem. In 2020 it was announced- Mm ... somewhere during the mid of COVID or so. I think that’s a, that is a landmark, moment, to be honest.
the few companies existed even before that.
But the true, you know, acceptance came in 2020 when it was liberalized. Although we, we only started in 2021, but one year before it started. So I think I won’t call it as a reorganization, but I think it was structured in a very different way now. And, post the liberalization, I think IN-SPACe was formed, which is I...
which probably is one of the best things that has happened to the private space ecosystem in India, because they have become the single window authorization, you know, authority for us. Anything and everything, a startup and a private ecosystem can just go to them, talk to them, and resolve their problem and keep moving, right?
So you don’t have to kind of figure out that who all I need to go to and talk to, to resolve some of my things. We have, we have saved a lot of time because of IN-SPACe, right? So I think now what is happening is the other wing of Department of Space, which is ISRO, which is what we know as, you know, something that has really, really heavy lifted, the load of innovating and building things in India and making India, you know, one of the space-faring nations.
So ISRO has done tremendously well. And now they’re probably exploring more deep space missions. Like, you know, Chandrayaan 3 is a classic example of that. And, they’re looking at human spaceflight, they’re looking at, you know, measurements on sun, and so on and so forth, and which is very critical because these technologies then trickle down on a commercial domain to build businesses later, right?
How things behave in space is the, is the most toughest environment, and then if you take the same technology and put it here, it’ll definitely work. So, you know, I think ISRO is going that way, which also gives private companies a lot more to, you know, repeat and build businesses on top of it. So, so I guess Indian Space Policy also came just after that, the draft. And then, of course, you know, the guidelines are on the way. Liberalization in space, Indian Space Policy, Space Situational Awareness Policy, now the guidelines. I would say all these things are really, really pivotal in terms of policy reforms that has been given to the Indian private ecosystem. Then there are opportunities, you know, that have come up.
For example, you know, all these seed fund schemes that, they run, as IN-SPACe. They give you very specific problem statements to work on, and it is upstream to downstream. They also give you agriculture use cases that, you know, how do you use satellite imagery to solve some problems, right? like a sugarcane retooling problem.
I mean, probably a lot of people can’t imagine that I can use satellite imagery to solve for a sugarcane retooling problem and quantify that. Then I’ll go a little bit up, right? How do you do the missions management? So can you do a mission virtualization? Can you build a digital twin of your satellite, right?
And then can you, can you make a better simulation software for a rocket engine? There are a bunch of, you know, problem statement that, that is being thrown at the private ecosystem to solve for and probably use that as a business model to sell. And then, of course, a bunch of other projects and schemes that have come together.
So I, I guess it’s, you know, m- it’s IN-SPACe that is... has become a boon to the private space ecosystem right now to do a lot.
Pranav Agarwal: That is fascinating. So you start in 2021. You already have the idea of doing the OptoSAR at that point?
Suyash Singh: Yeah. Just at that point, yes
Pranav Agarwal: And then your first launch happens in 2026, right?
So there is a half a decade difference between the two. What actually happens in those five years? What does it take to go from this idea that this is something that we can do to actually getting a satellite up in space?
Suyash Singh: I think a lot again, right? So, let me speak technically first. right, from a technology standpoint, you know, our assumption and reality was very different when we started. We said we want to innovate on OptoSAR, which means the first idea that came to our mind is can we take an optical from the market and the SAR from the market and then put our synchronisation layer and just make it happen? But when you take the shopping bag and go into the market, you’ll find nobody is building a SAR You know, in a private context.
And, the kind of pricing that you’ll get from a foreign vendor to build SAR for you is, is, is a startup can’t afford. So, you know, then you have to kind of say, “Okay, can I build first a SAR, and then I’ll think about an OptoSAR?” So the step one was for us to build a SAR, and that was also a moment of realisation that probably there are no SAR companies in the country.
You know, so beyond O- OptoSAR, there’s also a dearth of, you know, the, the players who can build SAR. So, you know, you start to get those problems with the subset of problems that you never imagined. So I think for us it was how do we build an optical or rather take an optical from somebody, build a SAR, build systems around it?
That was the first thing that came to our mind. So I said, “Okay, here is a strategy. We can do it.” Next question. Should we put it together and then launch and then reiterate and understand? The answer is no, that you, you know, you’re based in India, you will not be able to find that kind of capital to iterate in space.
You know, you can’t send up and then, you know, learn from it and do it again and again. Maybe you will have one or two attempts. So we said, “Okay, you know, it is better to maybe test out systems in a much more frugal manner.” So what we did is we miniaturised the SAR and optical in such a way that we can put it on a aircraft or a drone or a HAPS.
We did all, by the way. So we miniaturize it to a level where we can fly it on an altitude of, say, 200 meters, then take it to a kilometer, and then take it to a four-kilometer height, take it to a eight-kilometer height, and then send it to space. So for us, the first three years were all about testing whether my sensor really works in a limited environments, like how you do a POC or a, you know, pilot project.
We just did our own pilot by miniaturizing that sensor stack and putting it on drone. But that was also tough. I’ll tell you why. Drones are quadcopters that vibrate a lot. Space is much more stable. So you can put things on drone, but then you have to solve now more problems, and the problems now are the vibration.
How do you do signal processing with that kind of vibrations? It’s a much harder problem to solve. In fact, we have wrote papers more than on drones signal processing than on space signal processing. But in hindsight, that helped us save a lot of costs, although it was much harder problem to solve. So I think first three years just went into solving this technology and then getting confidence into putting on, on a satellite.
So satellite was a relatively solved problem, so we, we were confident enough to kind of go out in the market and outsource a lot of components, and we did. We did that. So, and then, you know, put ... After the R&D of OptoSAR, we got the OptoSAR and we got the satellite things outsourced, final thing was to do assembly.
So, but satellite programs run longer. It takes at least two to three years to build the kind of satellite that we’ve built. S- Do the program management, long lead items. Some items takes up to 14 months to get manufactured. The smallest of the sensors, the FPGAs and so on and so forth. And finally, you know, then you have to book the launch, and you have to manage and match the launch timing.
You may miss a launch window if you’re three months here and there, two months here and there. So, so program management is also something, you know, that we did for the last five years. So technically, I think it was more to do R&D, very deep R&D on sensors, putting it together and sending it to space.
Pranav Agarwal: So help me understand what you’re thinking as a CEO at this point, right?
Because I think the revenues I imagine would only start rolling in once your satellite is in space. Until then, you have extremely expensive components. You have extremely expensive, like, testing environments. You have all of these different problems. and I mean, that is just money going out and nothing coming in.
So how do you think about the financial situation that you have before you can get your first launch up?
Suyash Singh: That’s a, that’s a great question. So I, I don’t know if I have an answer to that or not, but s- but, you know, one of the things that we believe is, A, you need to onboard investors who are in it for a longer term, right?
Who are in, who are interested in deep tech and who see value in investing in deep tech and staying invested for longer term. So I think that is one of the most critical aspects that I would say, you know, we had to subscribe to it and was very happy with the investors that we’ve gotten onboard. Super happy about them.
secondly, I would say, you know, there are two things. If, if you’re, if you start to get those smaller opportunities on the way- And you start monetizing those smaller things. For example, we did a drone, right? And, we wanted to sell the drone payloads to maybe the drone market, right? And then run a bunch of algorithms and build analytics on the way.
So these things are very good, but, you know, also distracts the long-term aspects. So I think, you know, you need to find the balance. I, you know, it’s ... I, I won’t say that doing analytics is wrong, right? Because we ourselves have done it, and we’re fairly successful on that. But, you know, sometimes you have to choose the lower-hanging fruits very cautiously during the time you’re invested to build your first asset, first milestone of, you know, either sending a rocket up there or sending a satellite or doing whatever you’re trying to do.
To be patient enough to do that, and you need to find those patient investors who at least be patient enough to that particular milestone. So I, I feel that is a very critical thing to this particular point. But in the meanwhile, you have to also really generate the excitement in the market I think our team did a great job in interacting with, a lot of customers.
And, you know, it was even we were deep tech, we didn’t have the product. We, we had more presentations to show or other sample data from drone to show. But we went across everywhere, you know, interacted with as many as people as possible to understand if this is what they’re really signing up for or will they sign up for or not.
A lot of customers, you know, were educated en- enough to say, you know, I mean educated in these terms, not in the regular terms, to say that this is what I want. And a lot of other customers got to know for the first time that, okay, this can happen also. So I think, you know, while we have to wait for the milestone, but that doesn’t say that you should not go and talk to your customers.
You should talk to them, build enough excitement, get as many as feedbacks, because we got some critical feedbacks on the way into development. Somebody said, “I don’t need this band.” And that was a constant feedback across the range of customers. And we chose to do that band because we were thinking from a science perspective.
So we said, “Okay, now remove this band. There’s no point in doing that,” right? So I think these are the things that you do for that entire longer phase.
Pranav Agarwal: I think one of the most interesting things about this whole space tech ecosystem that’s coming up is that this is a system that has to, by its nature, sort of live and breathe R&D.
And I think more broadly right now we’re in this moment of national reckoning where we’re suddenly realizing that, oh, we’re only spending a nothing percent of our GDP on R&D, and we are not going to be taken seriously as an economy unless we can keep bringing new ideas to the fore. Right? But I think for a lot of industry, it’s not entirely clear about how do you even start this R&D process, you know, off.
If you were to talk to Indian industry, as someone who has done only R&D for years to, at an end, what would you tell them about the process, what they should think about, what their incentive should look like, et cetera?
Suyash Singh: Academic R&D and then the fast-tracked R&D, right? And then there is an incremental R&D. I would divide into these three portions, and you can pretty much think of TRL 1 to 3, TRL 4 to 6, and then TRL 7 to 9.
So TRL is technology readiness level. So there’s a very interesting scale that NASA has, designed to understand where your technology maturity is. So TRL 1 to 3 means, you know, you’re probably at a concept level or you’re doing extremely fundamental R&D to, you know, s- see what can happen in life like 10 years down the line, 15 year, 20 years down the line. But once it reaches a maturity, you know, people kind of take it to solve more serious problems between four and six. So technology readiness level four and six is beyond that pilot stage of those R&D levels, and you start solving some very good problems. Seven to nine is you’re actually packaging it and moving it to production, and at that time you only do incremental R&D.
When I used to be in academic, right, I would... or rather, a lot of MTechs and PhDs will not think about productizing anything and are going to market. They’ll not think about those things. They’re just solving a super hard science problem, right? Like, can I do, ... can I take the airplane wings and, you know, kind of make it telescopic so that when it is in air it comes back, and the moment I want to land I take it out?
Now, this is a hard problem. You can’t take risk with the aircrafts, so your wingspan is still very, very big. But can you make it telescopic? You know, like make it shorter and make it longer depending upon what are you doing. That is a very, very hard problem, very long-term problem which academia has to solve.
But as an industry or rather a startup, you know, you need to choose R&D problems that are solvable but also useful to the end customer. So the way we did our R&D was to solve a problem which was hard enough but was also in demand by the customers, right? So we were not like, “Okay, I will build OptoSAR and then see who wants our tech stuff,” right?
See, in general also, when we’re not talking about deep tech, we’re only talking about tech earlier, right? It’s still solving problems that a customer would want. It’s just that it was relatively easier to solve those problems. Like writing a software is a relatively easiest, easier problem. Building an app is a relatively easier problem, right?
It is that you know what to solve for and you build an app with a two-three member, five member, 10-member team maximum. I’m doing the same thing now, but the time it takes to solve the problem that I’m solving is, is much harder, or rather much longer, and the problem is much harder. So I think, you know, approaching let’s not do R&D for the sake of doing R&D because that academia is taking care of.
What we need to do is see whether there’s an exponential curve at the end of your R&D, you know, that gives you an upside in the demand side of the story. So, so I... if I have to say, you know, how one should approach an R&D in a startup environment and, you know, what all is happening in the country, there’s an excessive demand that is getting fulfilled by foreign players, you know, and that needs to be done here.
So we have not invested in those systems for last 20 years or so. The time is now, right? the recent RDI scheme that has come from the government is also going to allow people to do more, you know, with government money.
Pranav Agarwal: I think everyone intuitively understands the space is hard. I think beyond that, everyone’s intuitions immediately break down.
Nobody actually understands what it means for... what are the kinds of challenges that you actually face when you’re sending something in orbit in the middle of nothing. Could you help us understand the kinds of problems that you had to solve just because you had a spacecraft out there that someone would not even imagine could exist?
Suyash Singh: see, space is hard and, and, and the, the answer that I’m going to give you is, is, is going to surprise you also. Like, you know, the, the way why we think space is hard. Number one, space is hard because you cannot get an, get the asset back to repair. For example, you’re using an automotive car, you know, and the gearbox was faultier.
You’ll call the ge- all the automotive back to your service center, and you’ll change the gearbox and say, “Okay, great. You know, maintenance done. Mm. Kala bye-bye.” So, you know, there’s a lot of allowance to fail on ground, even on drones. You know, it ... You can take it back, change a few things, do something, and there’s zero tolerance in space because you just can’t read there, reach there.
So the, the, the, the fact that it is hard is the number one point about that is y- you can’t get it back to repair. Most of the things you can repair on Earth, right? But even if satellite is repairable, you just can’t get it back. So that is one thing that makes it super hard. Second is, second point, which is more, much more of a technical or other, or technical explanation, is you have very limited power in space. I mean, you can’t take a transmission line and power plug, you know, onto your satellite and say, “Okay, you know, I’m getting power from transmission lines.” So you’re only dependent on sun, which means you’re only dependent on solar panels. And you will see sun only for, say, 45 minutes in the orbit, and then you’ll see
You’ll, no, you won’t see sun for the other 45 minutes. So you have very limited power. The same asset with the power on Earth can operate for 90 minutes The same asset in orbit cannot operate for more than, say, 10 minutes because we are limited by power. Third point is the thermal cycling. When you’re seeing the sun, your temperatures can go the upside of, say, 125, 150 degrees.
When you’re not facing the Earth, you’re going to say a minus 50, minus 90 degrees. You know, imagine your body taking minus 50 and then 45 minutes later, 150. Or any of your, you know, things on Earth, like this glass of water. the, the glass takes m-minus 50 and then suddenly plus 150. It’s, it cannot sustain.
So you have to design your systems to go through that thermal cycling. And the last part maybe, and there are more, right? One of... One more thing that I would like to mention is the radiations. The radiations that you get on your electronics and, you know, can, can change entirely the way your satellite behaves.
Right? Like, your, your photon... sorry, your, microcontrollers work on zero and ones in your digital systems. The radiations can change those zero and ones externally.
And because of that, your code has to do something else.
Pranav Agarwal: The bit flips.
Suyash Singh: The bit flips. Precisely, right? So the bit flips can often happen because of radiation, and a particular s- algorithm is supposed to do a job.
It’ll get confused that, “What am I doing?” And then you’re in, probably in a constant loop in which it’ll never come back. So radiation affects the electronics, thermals affects the electronics, and, we’re limited by power, and we don’t have access.
Pranav Agarwal: So, I think SpaceX, of course, has become quite an institution for sending things up. I think, it’s doing hundreds of space, whatever, you know, missile launches.
Suyash Singh: Yeah, launches and then satellites also. 10,000 satellites and-
Pranav Agarwal: That also, yes.
Suyash Singh: Yeah.
Pranav Agarwal: So tell me what your experience is like talking to someone like SpaceX. What does a space company... How does it work for a space company that walks into SpaceX’s office and says, “Hey, I want to launch”?
And then what is the process from there to actually taking a satellite from Bangalore all the way to, I imagine, Florida, and then pushing it up? What is that entire process like?
Suyash Singh: It’s interesting, right? First of all, kudos to SpaceX, right? The way they have done, a lot of excitement in this entire ecosystem is probably because of them, right?
And they’ve mastered the art, like truly mastered the art, the way they do things and so on and so forth. Coming to your question more specifically, so SpaceX has done a great job in making you, you know, making their launch slot visible to you on a website or an app, like, you know, like a booking platform So, you know, for example, you’re, you’re booking a, a, a, an airplane ticket.
You can pretty much book on SpaceX a similar way, a l- you can book a launch. It’s as simple as that. So i- the moment you book the launch, right, they then get in touch with you to get more information about, you know, your, your asset, your payload, you know, legitimacy of your payload, et cetera. Then you get into a very simple agreement. And then there are payment milestones. So initially you’ll have to pay, say, 10 to 30%, then 50%, 60%. And, you know, the, over the course of your engagement and agreement, you, you are allowed to pay in milestones. So once that is done, you know, then there is the exchange of information that, okay, here is how you’re going to kind of attach the payload to the satellite, and that is the information that you’ll just share with them in a specific mode.
And then you, of course, before a duration of the launch, they’re going to give you a guidance that this is the time when you need to reach there. It’s like, you know, your bus is going to leave the station, your train is going to leave the station, so you will have to come at that particular point to hop onto that train to go.
So they’ll tell you the time to kind of come at that point in time, and you go there. The, the way you go there is, like, of course, your satellite is always built in a clean room environment. So to put that entire satellite in a portable clean room environment-
Pranav Agarwal: How do you do that?
Suyash Singh: So, so you, you need to kind of design a container that, that is a clean room by itself, which means it’s an airlock, and there are positive pressure gradients, gra- gradient that you create of the reverse way.
So any dust that may come inside, w- you will have to push it out. So it’s a portable clean room environment. And then, generally, you know, you can do a air freight. That’s easier if it’s a smaller satellite. It’s a bigger satellite, then you’ll have to find a shipping mechanism to go there. but you need, of course, to manage the loads, the vibrations, and other things that you have on the, on the ship or whatnot, or an aircraft.
The moment you land there, of course there are formalities like, like how you have to go through customs and, you know, the immigration and all that. So that you need to go through. And then you’re almost ready to integrate. Engineers help. The SpaceX engineers are always there, I would say almost 24 by 7, to help you and integrate the satellite onto the vehicle, and then they give you the smoothest ride into the orbit.
Pranav Agarwal: That is lovely. I imagine, like, one of the unique things about the space business, from what I can tell, is that so much rides on just that one launch day. You could do everything perfectly. You could nail every single step of the process, and there could be something, some missing heat shield, some pipe that has gone wrong, and everything just, you know, blows up.
What is that moment like emotionally? What are you thinking on the day of launch, and when can you finally go like, “Ah, it’s over”?
Suyash Singh: As a satellite company, you know, the job doesn’t stop at launch, by the way, but, but I’ll still tell you, during the launch, you know, you can see the, the kind of clinical approach of SpaceX towards their operations.
I mean, the, the launch vehicle goes, comes back. I have seen rockets going up. I’ve never seen a rocket going ... like coming back physically, and this time I saw that. It was mind-boggling. In seven minutes, it goes, leaves the satellite, like the final stage comes back and sits at the same point where it started from.
That’s mind-boggling. I think that is one. Second, I would say, till the time you’re separated, like, you know, generally separation is a bad word, but here the separation confirmed is, you know, brings you happiness that you know you’re finally in orbit, and that is one moment where, you know, the umbilical cord kind of gets separated, and you’re out of the rocket environment, and you’re finally in orbit.
To me, SpaceX by default brings you that trust, that, you know, that credibility that everything is perfect, and they have a minute-by-minute plan on literally everything Everything. Like, they know everything. They have a camera when they do the launch. Most of the launch vehicle don’t have cameras on board to, to see, and they do it live.
Like, they’re, they’re never scared of it.
Suyash Singh: So, so I think, you know, A, SpaceX brings in a lot of trust and credibility into the system. and hence, they also give you insurance, third-party insurance and all that for almost as a inclusive package. So with SpaceX, it’s slightly better, but, you know, there are upcoming launch companies and, you know, launchers that will come up. So Blue Origin was a little disheartening, you know, event. But, I must say, you know, rocket science is hard, but one who gets it is, is going to massively capture the market and become the, the most important person in the room. and SpaceX has done that. I’m sure there’ll be three or four more players will come who will
You know, on, on whose launch vehicle your anxieties are the less.
Pranav Agarwal: I think so far we’ve spoken a lot about space. I now want to think specifically about space as a business, right? one of the recurring problems that we saw when we were reading up was that there are a lot of people that would benefit immensely from the data that you have.
For instance, if I’m any farmer, for instance, if I could get the data feed of everything from soil health to water content to what the weather might look like, et cetera, et cetera, I would be enormously happy. but I will not pay for a satellite connection, right? I imag- From what we could tell, there were very few people that would actually take this as a recurring cost item on their books and would be able to absorb such a cost and would be able to justify such a cost.
Most companies that we saw, including the really big ones like Planet Labs, Maxar, et cetera, seem to have a anchor customer or maybe a couple of anchor customers, someone like the NRO, that takes care of most of their costs. And then you’re left with ... I mean, then you sort of start making your market beyond that.
How do you think about this process? How hard is it to actually get people interested enough to write you a check? how do you get them through the entire funnel? How does that, all of that work?
Suyash Singh: So I think more than that, how do we do it, I’ll just paint a picture of how do I feel the ecosystem is, right?
Number one, most of the market right now is, sits with the government or defense and, defense and security, the government agencies. Most of the market sits with them because they have no other option to rely on, you know, satellite imagery for a lot of their work. The second sector, which is commercial, right, is much smaller or rather slower right now. Because in commercial, people pay for value. If they’re not getting anything from satellite imagery or it is very inconsistent, they’ll always go back and say, “Yeah, I will try and find a better solution than what you’re offering me.” So number one, you know, most of the companies today are heavily reliant and dependent on the government or the defense and security users right now.
The way I feel it’ll evolve is the more consistent and the more or rather better quality images that the industry will bring on the table, the commercial market will start to unlock. Right? Now, you gave an example of farmers, right? And you’re absolutely right. they may not want to pay such huge sums to, you know, company to get, insight that they may use or they may not use.
But think of a hedge fund or a commodity trader, right? a commodity trader always wants to know when, you know, where is my stock. And if you think about a agri commodity or a mining commodity, right? If I tell you there are 10 tons of sugarcane that exists at this lat, long, and that lat long, and that lat long, their entire supply intelligence tool is in front of you.
Now, let’s go to other commodities. Palm oil, shrimps, you know, grains. So maybe, maybe i- in some of the countries, some of these agri commodities are regulated, but a lot, lot of them are not, which traders can actually use supply intelligence platform to do. Let’s go to mining commodity. Copper or, or, or rather metal commodities, you know, copper, where, where the stockpile is happening, how this thing will happen.
And, and one of the best examples is hedge fund basically did a case study where they used to capture all Walmart’s parking lot in 2018, using planet imagery, 20- 2019, using planet imagery, and they would count the number of cars. Based on that, they will estimate the demand of Walmart.
Pranav Agarwal: That is insane.
Suyash Singh: And they will break that break the stock market. So they would just estimate the demand based on the number of cars that are parked in the parking lot So I would say, you know, the hedge funds and commodity traders are still waiting for an appropriate solution to hop onto this entire thing, you know? So supply intelligence is probably one of the biggest things that people will actually, pay for in the future because it’s becoming slowly more digital.
People want to trust, validate whether there’s a supply or not. Some broker is just saying that, you know, “I have 10 tons of, sugarcane, but... or shrimps,” right? But it is not there. So how do you kind of, you know, get there? So one is that. Second, I would say defense and security and government is a very natural use case, right?
So, that’s, that’s the anchor customer that you’re talking about. One more interesting area is utilities, transmission lines, and oil and gas pipelines, and even oil companies. So if you want to know the vegetation encro- encroachment in the entire transmission network, your operations and maintenance, you know, plan gets much more refined.
Now you know where to go and prune the trees You know, you don’t have to kind of in middle of somewhere you do... Typically in India, we walk along the electricity lines to see where the vegetation is and then prune the trees, right? In, in, in, in some cases, we fly the drones, you know? But drones can only go so far.
If you’re to update that entire transmission line vegetation encroachment map every 30 days, you can’t fly drones over a network of ten thousands and hundred thousands of kilometers, right? This is where this comes in and says, “Okay, here’s the map. Here are the hotspots where you need to go and do the maintenance.”
Pranav Agarwal: I imagine a lot of people who stand to benefit a lot might still be reluctant to actually dive in and go for the technology. So do you find that friction? Do you have to educate people about, like, this is how we can help you? And what is that process like? How willing are people to listen to-
Suyash Singh: Huge friction.
Like, the friction is unimaginable, by the way. So I think the, the major point is, and it- which is quite true, by the way, people want to pay for insights. They don’t want to pay for data. I mean, if, if you are a commodity trader, and if I tell you, “Hey, here’s my data. Now you do your own analysis of where is shrimp, how much shrimp is available, how much copper is available, and whatnot and stuff,” you’ll be like, “I don’t want to build a R&D team on top of this imagery analytics and do,” and whatnot and stuff.
So I think there is still a gap between data providers and insight generators, right? And that gap is quite big currently, and that causes discomfort to anyone to com- kind of come and try satellite imagery. So which is what I was talking in the very beginning, right? The SaaS companies who can actually build an application to do operations and maintenance of all the transmission lines, they’re not getting the right data at a consistent pace to build a solution for their end users So imagine you’re a transmission company and I’m a SaaS company.
If I promise you that I will give you one image, one report of maintenance where ne- where it needs to be done every week, and I only didn’t get the images for three weeks because of clouds, then you’re gonna cancel the contract. Right. So I think that’s what is happening currently. But even, even if it is consistently available, the friction is who’s going to build that insights layer?
The company who is operating doesn’t want to build. As a data company, we are stretched to build it.
So we need some GTM partners who are very, m- like who are deep domain experts to build it.
Pranav Agarwal: So I have just a couple of questions of you. One of them is the way I see the space ecosystem, right, it’s actually many different kinds of businesses that are wrapped under the umbrella of space.
There is a different kind of business who’s trying to do launch. There’s a different kind of business who’s trying to make components. The different kind of business who’s doing what you’re doing, et cetera. So could you help me understand the map of India’s space industry? Where have we gone far ahead?
Where are we still lagging? What has gotten commoditised? What is still nascent? Could you just give me a sense of where things are?
Suyash Singh: Sure. So I think, I mean, I’ll probably take India as an example, right? see, most of the technologies are right now, you know, very siloed. Like, a lot of people are probably doing a component.
You know, somebody would do, a part of the component of the satellite, somebody would do a part of... or part or the component of a rocket. Now, a lot of these people, or a lot of these companies, you know, are more export-driven. They basically want to build components at scale and then sell it to different satellite manufacturers in India and abroad.
Now, it’s slightly hard problem to solve also because with the way geopolitics is happening around the world, you know, if, if India is not building hundreds of satellites, you, you know, you... And if you’re building hundreds of components, then you have to s- absolutely go outside and sell it. But the outsiders are evaluating are you a friendly foreign nation to kind of, you know, get these critical technologies, and they are also evaluating the readiness of India right now, right?
So I think component level we are probably doing good, but exporting them is hard, which means their pipeline and their revenues are still some time away. Now let’s come to the other side. People who are building systems, not components. They’re very few, right? You know, maybe there are a couple of rocket companies who are doing good, but then again, rockets’ job extremely hard problem to solve.
But their job is to, you know, take us as an Uber from one point to another and then drop us. so that is, you know, I think that’ll also happen. But what, where we have not been very, very active as a country so far is we don’t have enough satellite in orbit from a private ecosystem perspective. And from government also, I think, you know, since they have to do a lot, they have a limited number of satellites that they have been able to send up.
So what we really, really lack is if there are more number of satellites and more number of players who are building satellites- The component players will start to service their domestic market, then they will have to go to the export market. So the Indian space economy, the gap probably is in... You know, this metric has to be tracked, let me, let me say it that way.
The number of satellites, but not cube sats of five kgs or two kgs. I’m talking serious sat, which is 150 to 300 kg plus, which are very ser- into serious businesses, high-resolution satellites. Between... And even communication satellites will be somewhere around 250 to 300 kgs and above. That band of satellites and satellite manufacturers and operators is almost n- nil by, at this point in time.
Of course, we have made an effort from GalaxEye to kind of, you know, build a facility now to do 20 satellites of, 20 satellites a year of 300 kg class. So that is what we have built, as a facility, and we are, we’re all, we’re ready with that. But, you know, we probably will do 20, and then, of course, we need to see more demand to do hundreds and whatnot.
But we need more satellites. So I think one metric that we are not tracking in the space ecosystem in India is the number of serious satellites, and the serious is, like, 150 to 300 kg class.
Pranav Agarwal: Lovely. My final question is this. I imagine if you’re going into something like space, a lot... I would imagine you’re motivated by a larger vision.
For instance, Elon Musk very famously wants to create a Mars colony. I think a large part of his compensation now depends on whether he can get a Mars colony going. Do you have a long-term dream that you’ve gotten into this business with? Not... I know that in the medium term, you have X number of satellites, m- you know, metricized goals like that.
But for, say, a 50-year time horizon, do you have a dream that GalaxEye looks like this?
Suyash Singh: I won’t say a 50-year dream, but you know, I think our vision is to really unlock the power of satellite imagery. It’s not coming from the space perspective, but you know, the actual usage of satellite imagery, right? GPS today is an integrated, integral part of our life We want to make satellite imagery come to that GPS level.
You know, we want to make sure that satellite imagery gets utilized and benefits in agriculture, in healthcare, right? in whatever perspective, right? In defense and security, insurance, everywhere. So think of us as somebody who will, will become an app store, where a lot of these verticalised solutions will come and sit on top of it.
And we want to become that layer that drives satellite imagery to become a part of human lives. And, you know, humans should be able to use this technology for their benefits. I think that layer is what GalaxEye wants to kind of give it to the world.
Pranav Agarwal: It’s been lovely talking to you, Suyash. Thank you for being on the show.
Suyash Singh: Thank you so much, Pranav

